What Lies Beneath Ending Explained: Why the Ghost Was Haunting Claire (2024)

Director Robert Zemeckis' 2000 ghost movie What Lies Beneath has several layers to its mystery, but here's why Claire was being haunted. What Lies Beneath has oddly faded a bit from the popular consciousness in recent years, despite being directed by one of the most decorated filmmakers in Hollywood, and starring two hall of fame-caliber A-list actors in its leading roles. While reviews from critics were mixed, What Lies Beneath was a big box office success, nearly tripling its $100 million budget worldwide.

It's possible this fading away is the byproduct of the 2010s introducing so many options of things to watch that something like What Lies Beneath, a good but not excellent ghost story, fell by the wayside. Whatever the cause, Zemeckis' film is now streaming on Netflix, offering its millions of subscribers a way to either get reacquainted with the once very popular film, or discover it for the first time. After all, What Lies Beneath wouldn't be the first time a movie got a second life thanks to streaming.

Related: The Sixth Sense Wasn’t 1999's Best Ghost Movie

For those who have seen What Lies Beneath, there's a chance the twisty plot led to some confusion over what exactly happened to Claire (Michelle Pfeiffer), and why the ghost was haunting her. It's time to clear that up.

What Lies Beneath Ending Explained: Why the Ghost Haunted Claire

What Lies Beneath Ending Explained: Why the Ghost Was Haunting Claire (1)

Throughout What Lies Beneath, Claire (Pfeiffer) is haunted by a female ghost, and at first believes it to be her neighbor, who's seemingly disappeared after a fight with her husband. However, the neighbor eventually returns, and it turns out this haunting is a lot more personal. The ghost is a young woman named Madison Elizabeth Frank (Amber Valetta), who was having an affair with Claire's professor husband Norman (Harrison Ford). As is often the case in horror, Norman and Claire's bright suburban existence was only a facade covering a dark reality, as not even a seemingly ideal marriage was enough to prevent Norman from cheating on his wife.

Since Madison is a ghost though, Claire quickly begins to suspect Norman was involved in her demise. Norman denies this, and being acted by Ford, he's pretty convincing, especially after Claire comes home to find him seemingly attempting suicide out of guilt over the affair. Alas, it's all a ruse, as Norman did indeed kill Madison, dumping her body in a lake, explaining why the haunting incidents kept revolving around water. Madison, Norman's student, had threatened to tell the dean at Norman's college about their affair

His dirty deeds exposed, Norman attempts to murder Claire too, but his plan fails, and the couple ends up in the lake, leading Madison to get revenge on her killer. While it's certainly been the message of more than one horror movie, What Lies Beneath's ending again reinforces the idea that secrets tend to get revealed, and crimes tend to get uncovered, and attempting to (sometimes literally) bury them only leads to worse problems for all involved.

More: Why Harrison Ford Is Angrily Pointing In Almost Every Movie

Your changes have been saved

Email Is sent

Please verify your email address.

You’ve reached your account maximum for followed topics.

Manage Your List

Follow

Followed

Follow with Notifications

Follow

Unfollow

What Lies Beneath Ending Explained: Why the Ghost Was Haunting Claire (2024)

FAQs

What accident did Claire have in What Lies Beneath? ›

Claire comes to her senses and the memory of her own car accident returns as she remembers that she had caught Norman and Madison together. Distraught by the discovery, she had crashed her car into a tree while driving in a rain storm.

What happens at the end of What Lies Beneath? ›

Norman grabs Claire's leg so that she cannot escape, but Madison's corpse grabs Norman, drags him to the bottom of the lake, and forces him to release Claire's leg so she can float to the surface. Once Norman was drowned, Madison's corpse flashes a creepy smile, pleased that he is dead and that Claire is safe.

Why did she smile at the end of What Lies Below? ›

Libby awakes in a row of water tanks containing other women apparently in pupae. As water fills her tank, she initially bangs on the glass but then smiles when she realizes she can breathe underwater.

What happened to Claire's first husband in What Lies Beneath? ›

Claire briefly mentions to Stan (Ray Baker) Baker and his new "squeeze" Elena (Wendy Crewson), while the four of them are dining in the restaurant, that Caitlin's father (and Claire's first husband), whose name was Michael Marlowe, was also a musician and that he died.

Who killed Madison in What Lies Beneath? ›

Norman agrees to confess and calls the police, but Claire discovers he dialed 4-1-1 instead. He paralyzes her with halothane, admitting that he murdered Madison when she threatened to expose their affair to the dean.

What happened in the boat in What Lies Beneath? ›

The scene shows John taking Libby out on a boat to help him catch more lampreys. While they are on a boat, she suddenly gets her period, which is followed by strange behaviour from John. He reaches towards her crotch and licks the blood, and even smells her clothes when she is in the shower.

Who is the villain in What Lies Beneath? ›

Norman Spencer is the main antagonist of the 2000 horror film What Lies Beneath. He was portrayed by Harrison Ford, who also portrayed Allie Fox in The Mosquito Coast.

What Lies Beneath Who is the killer? ›

At trial the truth finally emerges and the identity of the killer is revealed. In the end, the killers are Rob's wife Sabrina and her lover Jonathan Hearn.

What happens at the end of the lie explained? ›

In the very final shot of The Lie, Kayla is hugging her parents while the doorbell rings. We hear sirens outside, and we assume the police are here to arrest Kayla's parents. The moral of this story is: Don't lie to your parents, or they might commit murder (or at least serious assault) on your behalf.

What was in the water in What Lies Below? ›

Libby discovers her mother trapped in a water tank in the basem*nt, where John is attempting to force her to birth an unseen fish-human hybrid. Fortunately, she's able to briefly free her and make a run for it as John transforms into his fish-person self and vomits up a strange blue light.

Why did Libby bleed in What Lies Below? ›

Libby starts to menstruate and when John sees the blood, he attempts to clean it up with his shirt, and touches her. They return to the house and while Libby showers, John sneaks into the bathroom to smell Libby through the curtain.

Who is the daughter in what lies beneath? ›

The film takes its time in laying out the story of high-strung Claire (Michelle Pfeiffer), who is dissolving into hysteria on a regular basis. Her daughter (Katherine Towne) has just gone off to college. And Claire is still recovering from the trauma of a car accident of a year before, when she was behind the wheel.

What is the story behind What Lies Beneath? ›

Who is Claire kidnapped by? ›

In the meantime, Claire is taken by the Browns and Marsali is left unconscious. Lionel Brown wants revenge for Claire's page in the paper about how to prevent a pregnancy, which was published under the name "Dr. Rawlings".

What happens to Claire's first baby? ›

Following Claire's dangerous pregnancy, Faith was stillborn in Paris at L'Hôpital des Anges.

What Lies Beneath Norman's death? ›

Once the true nature of Norman's crimes comes to light, the film becomes a race for survival as he tries, and fails, to murder Claire. But she outwits him and, in the end, the spirit of Madison Frank helps drag him to a watery grave.

What is What Lies Beneath about summary? ›

What house was used in What Lies Beneath? ›

The Spencers' house, a Nantucket-style mansion (with stunning views) that was built specifically for the film and then immediately torn down after shooting, appears to be located beside the Lake Champlain Bridge in Addison, which would make for a rough commute to Burlington for Norman.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Barbera Armstrong

Last Updated:

Views: 6262

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Barbera Armstrong

Birthday: 1992-09-12

Address: Suite 993 99852 Daugherty Causeway, Ritchiehaven, VT 49630

Phone: +5026838435397

Job: National Engineer

Hobby: Listening to music, Board games, Photography, Ice skating, LARPing, Kite flying, Rugby

Introduction: My name is Barbera Armstrong, I am a lovely, delightful, cooperative, funny, enchanting, vivacious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.