When it comes to venture investing, the focus is often on identifying the next big thing, the next unicorn that will bring in massive returns for investors. But while finding the right companies to invest in is certainly important, it's equally crucial for investors to have a solid exit strategy in place.
What is an Exit Strategy and Why is it Important?
An exit strategy is a plan for how investors will eventually sell their stake in a company and realize their returns.
Manage Risk and Align Interests with Exit Strategies
Exit strategies are an essential part of the venture investing process for a number of reasons.
Manage risk - First and foremost, they help investors to manage risk. Investing in startups is inherently risky, as many of these companies will fail to achieve the kind of growth and success that investors are hoping for. By having a clear plan for how they will eventually exit an investment, investors can mitigate some of this risk and ensure that they have a way out if things don't go as planned.
Alignment of Interests - Another key benefit of exit strategies is that they help to align the interests of investors and entrepreneurs. When investors and entrepreneurs are on the same page about how and when investors will exit a company, it can help to build trust and collaboration between the two parties. This, in turn, can help to drive better outcomes for both sides.
Common Exit Strategies for Venture Investing
There are a number of different exit strategies that venture investors can use, each with its own pros and cons. Some of the most common exit strategies include:
Initial Public Offering (IPO): An IPO is when a company sells shares of its stock to the public for the first time. This is typically the most lucrative exit strategy for investors, as it can lead to significant returns if the company's stock performs well. However, IPOs are also unpredictable and can be difficult to time correctly - especially in volatile investment climates, like the one we are in today.
Acquisition: An acquisition is when another company buys out a startup. This can be a good exit strategy for investors who are looking for a quicker return on their investment, as acquisitions can often happen relatively quickly. However, acquisitions can also tend to result in lower returns for investors than IPOs.
Secondary Market: A secondary market is a marketplace where investors can buy and sell shares in private companies. This can be a good option for investors who want to exit a company before it goes public or gets acquired. However, secondary markets can be illiquid and it can be difficult to find a buyer for your shares.
Buyback: A buyback is when a company repurchases shares of its own stock from investors. This can be a good option for investors who are looking for a quick and easy way to exit a company. However, buybacks tend to result in lower returns for investors than IPOs or acquisitions.
Factors to Consider When Choosing an Exit Strategy
Each of these exit strategies has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice will depend on three factors, including:
One key consideration when it comes to exit strategies is timing. The timing of an exit can have a significant impact on the returns that investors receive. If investors exit too early, they may miss out on significant upside potential. On the other hand, if they wait too long to exit, they may be stuck with an illiquid investment that is difficult to sell.
To avoid these pitfalls, investors need to have:
1. A clear understanding of the market and the factors that are driving growth in the companies they are investing in.
2. Agility - They also need to stay on top of industry trends and be prepared to adjust their exit strategy as needed based on changes in the market.
3. Clear communication - Investors need to be transparent with entrepreneurs about their plans for exiting a company and the timeline they are working on. This can help to build trust between the two parties and ensure that everyone is working towards the same goals.
Recommended by LinkedIn
4. Collaborative Spirit - Investors need to be prepared to support entrepreneurs through the exit process, which can be very complex for anyone going through it for the first time.
5. A strategy!
Investors need to understand the importance of creating a solid exit strategy before investing in a startup. This strategy helps investors maximize their returns on investment and minimize their risk.
One of the main reasons why investors need to have an exit strategy in place is that startups are inherently risky investments. Many startups fail to take off, and even those that do have a chance of failing in the long run.
At R3i we invest in founders first, but also patent-backed technologies or companies with a strong data moat - this gives us an asset to sell, even if the team were to fail. Having an exit strategy is crucial because it provides investors with a way to get their money back if things go wrong.
Moreover, an exit strategy also provides a way for investors to capitalize on their investments if the startup becomes successful. It allows us as investors to sell our shares in the company and take a profit, which can be reinvested in other startups or used to grow our own franchise, and most importantly, to deliver back the principal investment and return 80% of the profits to our Limited Partners.
Working with Founders and Management for a Successful Exit
While everyone talks mostly about exit strategies via an initial public offering (IPO). In an IPO, the company sells shares to the public for the first time, allowing investors to sell their shares on the open market. While this strategy can be very lucrative, it is an expensive process, requires a lot of preparation and planning, and puts a significant regulatory hurdle on the future listed company.
Another common exit strategy is a merger or acquisition. In this scenario, a larger company buys the startup, allowing investors to cash out on their investment. This strategy is often less risky than an IPO, but it can also be less profitable.
Investors can also opt for a partial sale of their shares, which can provide them with some liquidity while still allowing them to maintain some ownership in the company. This strategy can be useful for investors who want to stay involved in the startup but also want to diversify their portfolio.
It's important for investors to have a clear understanding of their exit strategy before investing in a startup. This helps them make informed decisions about their investment and provides them with a roadmap for success. Investors should also be aware that their exit strategy may change over time as the startup evolves and market conditions shift.
In addition, investors should also work closely with the startup's management team to ensure that the company is well-positioned for an exit. This includes developing an exit strategy with identified strategic companies for each of those strategies that are carefully engaged throughout the life of a company.
The company should build a strong and defensible business model, a talented and diverse team, a solid top line of revenue and customers, and establish a strong track record of partnerships to accelerate outcomes, and success.
Ultimately, the success of an exit strategy depends on a variety of factors, including market conditions, the startup's performance, and the investor's goals. By creating a solid exit strategy and staying informed about market trends, investors can maximize their returns and minimize their risk when investing in startups.
Pitfalls and Schemes to Avoid When Exiting Your Company
We all know how it goes. We have killed ourselves to get here, sacrificed time with our loved ones and families, paid our team and partners first before ourselves for years, and lived a journey with our investors, team and customers, unlike any other - and now the time has come for that exit.
But lookout - not everyone has your best interests at stake!
Beware the "Pump and dump" - this is an illegal scheme in the financial markets where an individual or group artificially inflates the price of a security through false or misleading statements to encourage others to buy the security, and then sells the security at the inflated price to make a profit.
In the context of startups, the scheme typically involves investment bankers or private investors targeting a startup founder or team and convincing them to artificially inflate the company's valuation through false or misleading statements or promises of future funding. This may involve manipulating financial metrics or creating false hype around the company's prospects.
Once the valuation is inflated, the investors will then sell their stake in the company at the inflated price, leaving the founder or team with a significantly overvalued company and potentially facing legal consequences for their involvement in the scheme.
An example of this could be an investment banker convincing a startup founder to falsely claim that the company has secured a large partnership or investment, which would significantly increase the company's value. The investment banker may then use this false claim to attract other investors and artificially inflate the company's valuation. Once the valuation is inflated, the investment banker or other investors may sell their stake in the company at the inflated price, leaving the founder with an overvalued company that is unlikely to attract legitimate investment in the future.
Ouch!!! Avoid. Avoid. Avoid.
Other pitfalls and schemes that founders should be aware of when exiting their company include:
Importance of Legal and Financial Advisors in the Exit Process
Exiting a business can be a complicated process, with many legal and financial considerations. Whether selling a business, merging with another company, or simply closing down operations, it is crucial to have the right legal and financial advisors in place to guide you through the process.
Your legal and investment banking service provider bench, while often expensive, is worth its weight in gold here. It's essential to work with experienced legal and financial advisors who can help identify and mitigate these risks during the exit process.
Legal Advisors
Legal advisors play a critical role in the exit process. They can help you navigate complex legal issues, such as drafting and negotiating contracts, reviewing and assessing risks and liabilities, and complying with regulatory requirements. Their expertise in legal matters can help you protect your interests, minimize risk, and ensure that all legal requirements are met.
A legal advisor can also help you structure the transaction in a way that maximizes your financial gain. For example, they can advise on the most tax-efficient way to structure the deal, helping you save money and avoid unnecessary tax liabilities.
Additionally, legal advisors can provide valuable guidance on dispute resolution and litigation. Should a legal dispute arise, they can provide legal representation and help resolve the issue quickly and efficiently.
Financial Advisors
In addition to legal advisors, financial advisors are also critical in the exit process. They can help you assess the value of your business, identify potential buyers or merger partners, and develop a strategic plan for exiting the business. Their expertise in financial matters can help you maximize the value of your business and minimize the risk of financial loss.
Financial advisors can also help you negotiate the terms of the transaction, ensuring that you receive fair value for your business. They can provide valuable insight into the financial implications of the transaction, such as the impact on your taxes and cash flow.
Finally, financial advisors can help you develop a plan for managing your finances after the exit. Whether you plan to retire or start a new business, they can help you make the most of your financial resources and ensure a smooth transition.
The reality is that legal and financial advisors play a critical role in the exit process. They can help you navigate complex legal and financial issues, protect your interests, and ensure a smooth transition. Working with experienced legal and financial advisors can help you maximize the value of your business and minimize the risk of financial loss, making the exit process a successful and profitable one, and maximising returns for all.
Take back to the office
In conclusion, exit strategies are a critical component of venture investing, allowing investors to manage risk, align interests with entrepreneurs, and maximize their returns on investment.
The most common exit strategies include an IPO, acquisition, secondary market, and buyback.
The choice of exit strategy depends on various factors, including the stage of the company, industry, and investor goals.
It's important to work closely with founders and management to ensure that the company is well-positioned for an exit, and to avoid pitfalls and schemes such as insider trading, misrepresenting financials, bribery, and unfair acquisition terms.
Finally, engaging experienced legal and financial advisors is crucial in navigating the complex exit process and mitigating legal and reputational risks.
With a solid exit strategy in place and careful planning, investors and their founders and teams, can all achieve a successful and profitable exit.
For only together can we accelerate impact!
About the Author
Leesa Soulodreis the General Partner of R3i Capital,a global sustainable development venture capital fundinvesting in climate change adaptation and the transition to value-based healthcare. Reach out if you would like to learn more about our mission in theR3i Future Fund.
What’s in our name?
R3i stands for returns, resilience and reliability — three characteristics that are often used to describe or evaluate investments, businesses, or other assets.
Together, these three characteristics can be important factors to consider when evaluating the potential risks and rewards of an investment or asset.
3 i’s — “Intelligence, Innovation, and Insight” are the three characteristics that are often used to describe a venture firm’s edge. R3i synthesises these into its collective and inclusive “impact”.
