How to Determine Whether You Should Reupholster or Buy New Furniture (2024)

A Little Design Help{ Discover the Designer in You }

Posted on March 19, 2012 by Teri2 Comments

If you have an old, worn-out sofa, chair or bench in your possession, chances are you have considered having it reupholstered. But, is reupholstery always the best choice? Here are some points to consider before making your decision.

First, consider the age of the piece you are considering for reupholstery. Is it an antique? Is it a newer piece? Often, it pays to have an antique or older piece of furniture reupholstered, as they are often hard to replace. If your piece has sentimental value, such as grandma’s antique rocking chair, reupholstery is less a question of money, and more a must-do project.

Consider, also, the quality of your piece. Since reupholstery is not an inexpensive project, it doesn’t often make sense to spend the money on a piece that could be replaced with a new one at a lower cost. For example, in my professional experience, it costs around $2,000 to reupholster an average sofa. This includes fabric and labor costs. Although the prices will vary based on your location, fabric choice, and whether you can do the reupholstery yourself, it clearly doesn’t make sense to spend that amount of money on a sofa that only cost $500 to start with.

If you don’t know the cost of your piece, you can look at a few different things to determine its value. First, check whether the piece has springs or not. The best upholstered furniture has hand-tied springs beneath the seat cushions, while lower-quality furniture uses sinuous springs to support the cushion (see my previous article on this topic). Second, lift one end of the piece (if you are able to do so safely) and feel how heavy it is. The heavier the furniture, the more solidly constructed the frame is. Finally, consider whether your piece has been reupholstered in the past. If it has, chances are good that it has lasted many years already, and may be worth investing in again.

Here is the exception to the “cost” rule. If you have a piece of furniture that you love, and it fits in the room just perfectly, it may be worth reupholstering it regardless of cost. Sometimes, finding just the right piece of furniture for your room is a difficult task. Keeping it once you have it, especially in tricky spaces, may well be worth the cost of reupholstery.

Tips for Success:

  • When you price out a reupholstery project, don’t forget to determine whether your existing cushions can be saved. If they are saggy or worn, have the upholsterer price out new foam for your furniture piece; it will be worth the cost, as the cushions are the first things to wear out on a piece of furniture. Reupholstering old foam in questionable condition isn’t a wise use of your design dollars.
  • Be sure to select a fabric that will hold up to the wear you expect your piece to see. If it will be a highly used sofa, for example, you may need a more durable fabric than you would need on an antique chair that is rarely used.

Pin It

Related posts:

  1. How To Select Quality Furniture
  2. How to Paint Stained Furniture for a Custom Look
  3. Susan Goldstick Gives Furniture, Accessories and Hardware a Unique Flair
  4. What Does “COM” or “COL” Mean?
  5. Save 20% on Furniture at Dwell Studio Through February 24, 2012

Filed Under: Design Inspiration, Furniture, How-To

← Find Local Savings With LivingSocial and Other Deals – March 16, 2012

No-Sew Bunk Bed Fort: A Great, Inexpensive Idea! →

2 Responses to How to Determine Whether You Should Reupholster or Buy New Furniture

  1. How to Determine Whether You Should Reupholster or Buy New Furniture (3)Jon says:

    January 16, 2013 at 3:56 pm

    When dealing with sentimental pieces, I completely agree that reupholstering is the correct route to take. Breathing new life into a precious or personal piece of furniture can be a very rewarding experience.

    Reply

  2. March 5, 2020 at 7:55 pm

    Having a rowdy dog is tough when you have an upholstered couch at home. It’s great that you mentioned that I should take into account the age of my furniture when considering if I should reupholster or replace it. The couch that my dog damaged was bought two years ago so I think it’s still relatively new.

    Reply

Leave a reply

How to Determine Whether You Should Reupholster or Buy New Furniture (2024)

FAQs

How to Determine Whether You Should Reupholster or Buy New Furniture? ›

It depends entirely on the quality of the sofa. If it's ordinary, reupholstering would cost more than buying a new one. If it's very high quality and you like the design, it is better to reupholster, even if that costs more than buying a cheap new one.

How do I know if my furniture is worth reupholstering? ›

You might want to reupholster a piece if you particularly like its design, if it matches other pieces in your home, if it fits perfectly in your space or if you have a sentimental attachment to it. You might also want to recover it because the fabrics you love aren't available on new pieces.

Is it better to buy a new couch or reupholster? ›

Though the cost to reupholster a couch varies, quality sofa upholstery could cost 50-60% less than replacement when all things are considered. Before calling upholsterers for quotes, measure your sofa and research fabrics. While pricier upfront, replacement sofas start cheaper but don't last as long.

Is it cheaper to recover a chair or buy a new one? ›

Though reupholstering can be a cost-effective alternative to buying new furniture—especially if you do it yourself—it's not always the less expensive option. More extensive repairs can cost as much as buying an entirely new piece, whereas minor repairs are usually more affordable and almost always worthwhile.

What is the average price to reupholster a couch? ›

Reupholstering a couch costs between $600 and $4,000, with an average cost of $1,750. Typically, you'll pay $50 to $70 per yard for fabric and between $40 and $100 per hour for labor.

How to tell a good quality couch? ›

A higher-quality sofa, on the other hand, will have the following construction.
  1. A Wooden Frame. This is key to a well-made sofa, but there are different frame factors to consider that that can impact durability.
  2. Good Suspension. ...
  3. Comfortable Cushions. ...
  4. Take Measurements to Ensure It Fits.
May 27, 2020

What's the difference between recovering and reupholstering? ›

Recovering and reupholstering mean the same thing - generally replacing the fabric, but not only. Recovering furniture is a mild form of reupholstering furniture. Recovering refers to loose items like pillows and reupholstering refers to furniture.

How do I know if my chair is worth money? ›

Our Antique Chairs Valuation Guide
  1. Age and historical significance of the chair.
  2. The state of the chair.
  3. Provenance of the chair's manufacturer.
  4. Demand Rarity Style Attractiveness and artistic flair.
  5. Size, quality, and materials of the chair.

Is it worth replacing sofa cushions? ›

Replacing your sofa cushions can breathe new life into your old couch, making it more comfortable and visually appealing. Over time, cushions can lose their support and shape, leading to discomfort and an unattractive appearance. Investing in new cushions can revitalize your sofa and extend its lifespan.

What time a year is it best to buy a new sofa? ›

If you want to buy indoor furniture for your kitchen, living room, or bedroom, consider visiting a store towards the end of winter, between January and February, or the end of summer, between July and August.

What is a good price for a new couch? ›

Affordable couches are less than $1000, suitable for budget-conscious shoppers. Mid-tier couches are priced between $1,000 and $2,000, offering a compromise between quality and cost. Premium couches exceed $2,000, crafted with high-quality materials and design features.

How long should a high-quality couch last? ›

Sofas last from seven to 20 years, though most cap out at roughly 15. The same goes for loveseats, sectionals and sleepers. Couches with solid wood frames (even better if it's kiln-dried) and reinforced joinery hold up the longest. Genuine leather upholstery has a longer lifespan than fabric.

How do I know if my furniture is worth restoring? ›

Evaluate the original quality of the piece. High-quality leather furniture, made from full-grain or top-grain leather, is typically more worth restoring than lower-quality alternatives. Determine if the furniture is a valuable designer or vintage piece. Such items often have greater resale and sentimental value.

What is the best way to check the quality of upholstered furniture? ›

Avoid upholstered furniture that is shaky or squeaky. Look at and feel the finish on the exposed wood parts. The surface should be smooth, attractive and free of blemishes. Springs provide upholstered furniture with an added measure of “give” and bounce, but not all upholstered furniture has springs.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated:

Views: 6322

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.